Poo Muffin
New Member
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2006
- Messages
- 14
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2006
Wow, my condolences to those that knew her and her family. The Board of Studies is responsible for a death.
If I was a lawyer I would sue them because they know of the stress, and they know of the ammount of suicides which has occured as a direct result of the HSC, yet they still haven't 'done' anything to reduce the stress for the students which will be doing the HSC.Poo Muffin said:Wow, my condolences to those that knew her and her family. The Board of Studies is responsible for a death.
No... not really.Odetosimplicity said:did anyone else cry when they looked at her myspace?
its just soo sad....
The HSC does not simply encapsulate the difficulties people face .. If it were something external which triggered her to do this, would she be taking the easy way out? Suicide is not an easy way out, it's a means for someone to attain relief, which most often may be deemed selfish .. but you don't know her (and I do think you need to know her); she may have suffered a health issue, a disorder of some sort, abuse, domestic violence - perhaps the HSC was instrumental in elevating her anxiety, but it is by no means her fault and I don't think her intention would have been to hurt those who love her (unless, they were hurting her) .. her control over the factors which stimulated this surpassed her and she made that choice.The Logical One said:No... not really.
We have to look at the bright side of life instead of the negative side. I honestly didn't know her and therefore have no right to be particularly sad. (as I have my own ordeal to face), It does phase you though that at the end of what is the HSC was so near, she decided to take the easy way out. My condolences go out to her friends and family.
People often make the mistake in believing that suicide is "When a person kills themself." I believe that suicide is "When a person kills the ones that care about them and love them." It's a difference in opinion and even though Riet, myself and others have that belief it is ours to have. I don't need to know the person to have my opinion on them. It is what she did, and if you are particularly saddened because you knew her then it proves my point.
I hope that the people who are effected may have the courage and the bravery to continue living the way they did prior to this happening. My condolences go out to you.
Suicide is not an issue to be flippant about. If you are feeling depressed, PLEASE seek help. Talk to people. Your friends, family, go see a counsellor. Please reach out.hscwillbehell said:I've contemplated suicide many a time over the past two years and my desire to follow through has been elevated by the HSC; yet, hindered because as you say, I sincerely do not want to hurt the people I love. Perhaps I may lose this control sometime, but for now, I will "bear the whips and scorns of time", as Hamlet would say.
Learn to read. I've been through hard stuff too, significantly more difficult than the HSC. If that's the reason why she did it that's just pathetic. Yes I feel sorry for you and her family and friends but I will judge her.misstoyou said:How can you presume to know what is inside another person? You have never even met Lily but you saw fit to post this without due consideration to the people who knew and loved her, who browse this site and could come across your arrogant views. Every person has their breaking point; that does not place you above or below Lily, she reacted to her situation as she saw fit, we will never know what prompted her action but it is not for you to judge. This is a terrible time for the people who knew Lily without you publishing your self-righteous opinions.
You cannot compare your experience to someone you know nothing about. No one kills themselves solely over the HSC. Even if someone were to, there would obviously be things going on for them internally to feel bad enough about the HSC to end their life. How dare you call a situation like that "pathetic".Riet said:Learn to read. I've been through hard stuff too, significantly more difficult than the HSC. If that's the reason why she did it that's just pathetic. Yes I feel sorry for you and her family and friends but I will judge her.
Just as every one has their breaking point, so does everyone have their right to express their opinion. You are the one coming across with your arrogant view that unless your post does not contain heartfelt condolences, it should not exist.misstoyou said:How can you presume to know what is inside another person? You have never even met Lily but you saw fit to post this without due consideration to the people who knew and loved her, who browse this site and could come across your arrogant views. Every person has their breaking point; that does not place you above or below Lily, she reacted to her situation as she saw fit, we will never know what prompted her action but it is not for you to judge. This is a terrible time for the people who knew Lily without you publishing your self-righteous opinions.
I think I can actually. I'm assuming there was much more too it than the HSC, and I as I said if that's the case then I would be more compassionate. When I say pathetic I'm making a generalised statement, not specifically directed at her, because as you say - I don't know the full story.dagwoman said:You cannot compare your experience to someone you know nothing about. No one kills themselves solely over the HSC. Even if someone were to, there would obviously be things going on for them internally to feel bad enough about the HSC to end their life. How dare you call a situation like that "pathetic".