You need to take lesson 101 in STATUS- the mechanism through which we develop attraction. Now, I’m sure intrinsically you are of equal status to the rest of us, but from a RELATIVE point of view, your impact on other's social value is NEGATIVE. You’re calling these women shallow? Who are you to make this call? It's not THEIR problem, nor is it their fault they are unattracted to you- it is YOURS. Put yourself in their shoes- why would they want to align with you? What perceived social value can you bring to the table which will add to their own- to improve their survival? Are you pre-selected by other women, the leader of your social group, protector of those closest to you? You need to demonstrate to these girls that you, Matt, are effectively better then all her other suitors. Now that demonstration certainly does not come from a place of desperation- first you need to be happy with just being ‘you’. There is nothing attractive about self-pity, crying over why people don’t like you. That’s just a ‘state’ of your neurology which can be literally changed in seconds, yet YOU actually prefer to operate this way (your producing the limiting belief) as the alternative involves hard work. For some inspiration, look up Sean Stephenson, the guy is successful with women, runs his own company and is 3 feet tall in a wheelchair!
YouTube - Sean Stephenson addresses a crowd about an interesting date!
So if your at the stage where you can't even answer with at least 5 strong points about WHO YOUR ARE then you are not ready to meet a woman. An attractive girl can go meet an attractive guy- someone who is confident, sociable, on their path, fit and healthy (notice I didn’t mention “good-looking” in the 21st century ‘next-top-model’ social conditioning sense of the word). I'm not saying you can't become any of these- but until you do, its simple economics dude. We all do the best with the resources we have- and in the dating market, attractive girls are in short supply with excess demand and that pushes the price up. At this current stage, it seems you have very little chips to bid.
I’d say good luck but that in itself would be paradoxical- luck is only a residue of design.