Predictions for Modern? (5 Viewers)

[utopianimal]

does anyone know what topics they HAVEN'T done for the longer response?

ik they still havent done appeasement/ collec secririty

 

[mdog2024]

Has anyone ever looked through the CSSA papers and seen how similar it generally is to the HSC? Like probability for predictive purposes

Has anyone got access to the CSSA for this year? Can't find it anywhere and our teacher didn't get it

 

[mdog2024]

ik they still havent done appeasement/ collec secririty

Isn't that more for conflict than core though?

 

[flyawaykay]

Surely Nuremberg --> pretty sure they've already done both early German success and Russian counter offensives

they haven't done either one

 

[beanbug]

Has anyone ever looked through the CSSA papers and seen how similar it generally is to the HSC? Like probability for predictive purposes

yes, just looking over the 19, 20, 22 cssa and hsc papers (2021 was nearly completely different) at least one of the essay question tests on the same dot point as in the trial papers. the short answers are a bit all over the place, but there's at least two dot points that are similar across them, just testing different specifics. you either get short answers the same or the essays the same. generally, the hsc essay questions seem to be more broad than the cssa papers.

 

[beanbug]

Has anyone got access to the CSSA for this year? Can't find it anywhere and our teacher didn't get it

ive got the power and authority section, im gonna ask my teacher for it tmrw! lmk if you want me to send u the section

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

yes, just looking over the 19, 20, 22 cssa and hsc papers (2021 was nearly completely different) at least one of the essay question tests on the same dot point as in the trial papers. the short answers are a bit all over the place, but there's at least two dot points that are similar across them, just testing different specifics. you either get short answers the same or the essays the same. generally, the hsc essay questions seem to be more broad than the cssa papers.

is this for Indochina btw?

 

[beanbug]

is this for Indochina btw?

2019 - essay q on cambodia and laos - hsc was effects on civilians and cssa was communist victory - the other question was entirely different
2020 - both questions were entirely different
2021 - both questions were entirely different
2022 - question on us involvement - cssa was changing nature of involvement 1954-1965 and hsc was reasons for withdrawl - other question was entirely different

lmk if you want specifics about the questions! i'm happy to send u the cssa ones as well if you would prefer. i'm doing indochina too, if you see/have any particularly good resources would you be able to send those to me?

 

[hihglightermmmm]

Hehe but yeah I think so. Just haven't ever sat down to directly compare. Might do it myself but I'm hoping someone's done it already

2019 - essay q on cambodia and laos - hsc was effects on civilians and cssa was communist victory - the other question was entirely different
2020 - both questions were entirely different
2021 - both questions were entirely different
2022 - question on us involvement - cssa was changing nature of involvement 1954-1965 and hsc was reasons for withdrawl - other question was entirely different

lmk if you want specifics about the questions! i'm happy to send u the cssa ones as well if you would prefer. i'm doing indochina too, if you see/have any particularly good resources would you be able to send those to me?

What about russia + Pacific have they tended to be similar?

 

[beanbug]

What about russia + Pacific have they tended to be similar?

russia:
2019- both different, the only similarity i could find was that cssa asked about the political and economic transformation under stalin and hsc asked about stalin emerging as the leader
2020- both different, happy to send you the cssa questions if needed.
2021- one question similar, about bolshevik ideology - cssa was the role it played in the power struggle in the 1920s and hsc was the extent the soviet state maintained the ideology
2022- questions were sort of similar - cssa was bolshevik ideology influcing social and cultural change in the ussr under stalin and hsc was about stalin's policies transform social and cultural life in russia.

pacific:
2019- both pretty similar, cssa about social, political and economic effects of war on civllians in s-e asia, hsc asked about effect of the war on civillians in s-e asia. other question in cssa was about japan's defeat, with a source about bombings (b-29 if) and hsc was about the use of the a-bomb in japan's defeat.
2020- both questions were different
2021- both questions were different
2022- both questions were different

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

2019 - essay q on cambodia and laos - hsc was effects on civilians and cssa was communist victory - the other question was entirely different
2020 - both questions were entirely different
2021 - both questions were entirely different
2022 - question on us involvement - cssa was changing nature of involvement 1954-1965 and hsc was reasons for withdrawl - other question was entirely different

lmk if you want specifics about the questions! i'm happy to send u the cssa ones as well if you would prefer. i'm doing indochina too, if you see/have any particularly good resources would you be able to send those to me?

yeah specifics would be great i have quite a bit of stuff for indo, what are you looking for in particular? btw tysm for comparing the 2 papers, seriously so useful and insightful

 

[hihglightermmmm]

Im having. nightmares of being given a question i havent prepped for and just being fucked

 

[beanbug]

yeah specifics would be great i have quite a bit of stuff for indo, what are you looking for in particular? btw tysm for comparing the 2 papers, seriously so useful and insightful

can i send you the specifics about the questions tomorrow?
anything about changing us involvement would be really good! also anything about laos and cambodia bc we ran oout of time to cover it please and thank you

 

[Dontcallmedude]

yes, just looking over the 19, 20, 22 cssa and hsc papers (2021 was nearly completely different) at least one of the essay question tests on the same dot point as in the trial papers. the short answers are a bit all over the place, but there's at least two dot points that are similar across them, just testing different specifics. you either get short answers the same or the essays the same. generally, the hsc essay questions seem to be more broad than the cssa papers.

Interesting. Thanks for the reply. Some practice is better than none. Histories broadness is one of the things that really detracts from enjoying the subject. Getting a question about something you aren't remotely interested in is the worst. Atleast we get semi-decent scaling.

 

[Harry_062]

Im having. nightmares of being given a question i havent prepped for and just being fucked

Donttt it is stressing me out too. Istg it’s always on the 1 thing I don’t prepare that is in it

 

[la_sportive]

View attachment 44822
This is what I'm thinking for the Pacific
(Also let me know if I got any of this wrong)

Yeah same. One thing is they did kind of allude to the advance in 2019, but yeah it's not been properly assessed...

 

[la_sportive]

Yeah same. One thing is they did kind of allude to the advance in 2019, but yeah it's not been properly assessed...

same with occupation in terms of slave labour etc was alluded to in the 2019 q but not explicitly mandated

 

[cheeseburger100]

any predictions for usa?

 

[radagastthebrown]

Yeah same. One thing is they did kind of allude to the advance in 2019, but yeah it's not been properly assessed...

Yeah, I'd noticed that as well, hopefully they ask a question on it

 

[la_sportive]

Yeah, I'd noticed that as well, hopefully they ask a question on it

Yeah I'm pretty confident in anything to do with the course of the conflict, so pearl harbour, early advance, turning points, allied strategy, a-bomb, and defeat, so praying that one of those comes up lmao
Otherwise eh it is what it is