Official Asian Cup 2007 Thread (1 Viewer)

[chocolate_lover]

oh well. i guess we did well with 10 men. i think this officially establishes Japan as our rivals. Even over Uruguay.

Yeah. IMO we were never really in this game, but we did well to last that long with only 10 men.

It depends on what angle you look at it from. The way I saw it that it was a pretty bad challenge and the red card doesn't look like it was unreasonable. It seemed as though Grella made a fist and hit Takahara's face.

Have you even seen footage of it?? He didn't make a fist, and it definitely wasn't worth a red.

 

[Evergreen]

If Korea wins against Iran I will be very very very happy. But I know it wont happen, Iran has been Korea's weakness for decades. So pretty much Iran advance Korea drops :mad1: .

 

[iamsickofyear12]

i'll take that as a yes, you are fat.

Take it as whatever you want... but I'm not fat.

 

[stazi]

Take it as whatever you want... but I'm not fat.

What's your myspace?

 

[iamsickofyear12]

What's your myspace?

How is that relevant?

 

[Evergreen]

YEH KOREA WON!!! GO KOREA!!!

Croud is going ballistic lol. Korea played a very good game vs Iran. Difficult but our goal keeper saved the game. 0-0 =======> Korean won on penalties
Iraq vs Korea next...

 

[wuddie]

my friend quote 'only if totti shot his penalty like lucas neill in the world cup'.

come to think of it, one can argue we lost both the asian cup and the world cup because of neill.

 

[timlay]

was he in the team which beat uruguay on penalties?

don't tell me "no" :O

 

[AsyLum]

It depends on what angle you look at it from. The way I saw it that it was a pretty bad challenge and the red card doesn't look like it was unreasonable. It seemed as though Grella made a fist and hit Takahara's face.

Oh well, as soon as they equalised I knew we were gone. Neill was at fault again. WTF's wrong with him.

There was barely any contact made at all, maybe a 'tad' clumsy, but it was a genuine challenge by two people going for the ball, one of the problems of a height advantage is that you do jump higher, and as a natural instinct, you raise your elbows for balance and movement. It was pretty frustrating to see the straight red when it was rather innocuous considering the way some of our players were apparently booked for 'simulation'

 

[matt#1]

How is that relevant?

He's clearly fat.

 

[LMF^^]

There was barely any contact made at all, maybe a 'tad' clumsy, but it was a genuine challenge by two people going for the ball, one of the problems of a height advantage is that you do jump higher, and as a natural instinct, you raise your elbows for balance and movement. It was pretty frustrating to see the straight red when it was rather innocuous considering the way some of our players were apparently booked for 'simulation'

I don't know how you can say that there was barely any contact. His arm hit Takahara's face, and Grella is no taller than him by any means. Yes it was a clumsy challenge, and Takahara came from behind so maybe Grella didn't see him coming. But the ref saw it differently, and probably from his angle it looked worse than it is. But nevertheless, such challenges can be deemed a straight red. This is the Asian Cup, and it is played and officiated differently to the more physical leagues such as the EPL and the A-League. The red card is arguable of course, depends on where you stand. I can understand that some may feel it's harsh, but I can accept the decision as being a reasonable one.

 

[matt#1]

I don't know how you can say that there was barely any contact. His arm hit Takahara's face, and Grella is no taller than him by any means. Yes it was a clumsy challenge, and Takahara came from behind so maybe Grella didn't see him coming. But the ref saw it differently, and probably from his angle it looked worse than it is. But nevertheless, such challenges can be deemed a straight red. This is the Asian Cup, and it is played and officiated differently to the more physical leagues such as the EPL and the A-League. The red card is arguable of course, depends on where you stand. I can understand that some may feel it's harsh, but I can accept the decision as being a reasonable one.

Mate, I respect your opinion but encourage you to watch the challenge again. It was an extremely soft red and a yellow at most.

 

[HeCtic]

The referee could justify that decision by saying he went by the letter of the law, but common sense in a ref is just as important and the guy in that match clearly had none. Never a red card ever.

He bottled so many decisions that night. Fucking terrible.

On another note, our next game is against the Argies in Melbourne. Can't wait to see Aimar , Messi , Riqueleme , Crespo , Ayala etc in the flesh.

Hope we get a proper coach by then, otherwise we could get a pounding.

 

[LMF^^]

Mate, I respect your opinion but encourage you to watch the challenge again. It was an extremely soft red and a yellow at most.

The replay of that challenge was shown repeatedly during the game, and from all those replays I still think it was a reasonable decision.

Now that Iran is a goner too I hope Iraq can win the tournament, that will be a story. But somehow I think that's unlikely and looks like it will be Japan again.

I heard the reporter on SBS said that the top 3 sides in the Asian Cup gains automatic qualification into the next Asian Cup, does anybody know if that's a new rule or something? Because China was runner up last time and they too had to qualify for this year's event.

 

[Evergreen]

Next game is Korea vs. Iraq on Wednesday. Will be a good game. Certainly won't be easy for both teams to win, I will be very happy if Korea can get through into the finals though.

Japan vs Saudi Arabia. I hope Saudi can win this won. It seriously won't be an easy game for Japan though I have a feeling Japan will win this one again.

 

[HeCtic]

The replay of that challenge was shown repeatedly during the game, and from all those replays I still think it was a reasonable decision.

Now that Iran is a goner too I hope Iraq can win the tournament, that will be a story. But somehow I think that's unlikely and looks like it will be Japan again.

I heard the reporter on SBS said that the top 3 sides in the Asian Cup gains automatic qualification into the next Asian Cup, does anybody know if that's a new rule or something? Because China was runner up last time and they too had to qualify for this year's event.

Haha, if a Manyoo player got a red card for something as innocuous as that you'd be filthy. I don't see how it was an acceptable decision.

It's good we didn't auto-qualify for the next cup too. The more competitive games we get the better off we'll be in the long run.

 

[LMF^^]

Haha, if a Manyoo player got a red card for something as innocuous as that you'd be filthy. I don't see how it was an acceptable decision.

It's good we didn't auto-qualify for the next cup too. The more competitive games we get the better off we'll be in the long run.

Rooney got a red in the Amsterdam tournament last pre-season, and he got suspended for 3 games in the league. I don't defend him now even if that one was a highly innocuous, even more so than this one involving Grella.

 

[stazi]

How is that relevant?

i want to add you to my myspace.

 

[iamsickofyear12]

i want to add you to my myspace.

There are no pictures on there if that's what you were thinking. I only have it there in case someone I used to know wants to find me.... I don't really use it.

 

[stazi]

do you have facebook? basically im interested in seeing what you look like. im looking for a new partner.