AlleyCat
Singing me and Julio
Oh
my
FUCKING
GOD
hi matt.
my
FUCKING
GOD
hi matt.
-
Finished your HSC? Check out our University Discussion, Non-School forums or help out next year's HSC students! -
YOU can help the next generation of students in the community! Share your trial papers and notes on our Notes & Resources page
Gang rape video (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter *hopeful*
- Start date
- Status
beentherdunthat
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2006
- Messages
- 1,132
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2007
I don't think you need to look at it from a muslim perspective to understand the situation. Firstly, she's only 17 years of age and is alone with 7 other horny guys in the middle of the night playing poker (Question: What the hell is she doing there?) . Secondly, she's drinking alcohol (Comment: That's illegal, you're supposed to be 18 to legally consume it... at 18 you're considered to be responsible enough) ... and like that chick said.. Xtinx... that the girl doesn't have a very clean history and that some of the people in the neighbourhood don't even believe it to be "rape".... Why would you assume she's not "slutty"?breaking said:
HotShot
-_-
SO just cause the rapists are WHITE -ITS not rape? OMFG...beentherdunthat said:
Then why would they send it around with phones and shit..
FUCKEN white wannabe TERRORISTS.
$hiftyIceQueen
Banned
Whats with you and the word terrorists?HotShot said:
HotShot
-_-
Harry Potter is a terrorist happy?$hiftyIceQueen said:
$hiftyIceQueen
Banned
Umm.. you cannot justify what they did.beentherdunthat said:
Yes she shouldnt have been doing somethings [eg drinking] BUT i dont see how her 'neighbourhood' could judge her, i mean "she fought to push the boys off" for gods sake !!! That obviously means she doesnt want to be a part of anything.
End of story
And HotShot, thats not very nice what did Harry do to you? Leave him out of this!!!!
seems to me like you have something for HP
HotShot
-_-
Its called being rascist - but once you use the word rasicst around here - everyone shit you called me racist - you cant do that and all that BS.Legham said:
Its obviously Breaking stereotypical view of muslims.
YankeeChica
Banned
I think they are innocent until proven guilty but for muslim its guilty until proven innocent.
HotShot
-_-
O wow you sound so COOL.. fuck yeah.YankeeChica said:
Hey look I think I am better than muslims.. but they mastermineded 9/11., London Bombings and Bali BOmbings and so they must be bunch of tards. and the national defense forces are even dumber.
..
..07hscer..
Member
why? do people do this
Not-That-Bright
Andrew Quah
Did I not say it was a ghastly act? There are varying degrees of how bad something can be, while her rape is absolutely a terrible incident, relative to forceful gang rapes involving weapons, insults, attacks etc it is a much less severe incident.
Perhaps "nothing" makes it appear too strong but I merely wanted to stress the fact that there appears to be a large difference here so that the OP can understand why maybe there isn't the same reaction to this as there was with the lebanese rapes - without evoking racism.
It has to do with their criminal culpability, their mens rea, more than necessarily how painful the experience was on the girl. To rape a girl whom you know cannot give consent because they are drunk, is different to planning/forcefully raping a girl who you know is not consenting. One requires a much higher level of unconscionable conduct than the other. The actual acts committed should also have some bearing imho.
I have no way of knowing whether subjectively for the girl this rape was worse on her than the 2000 rapes were... I am sure any of these experiences are painful for anyone and I don't want to judge them. What I'm judging is the difference of culpability between the perpetrators.
Last edited:
$hiftyIceQueen
Banned
Right, if they were so drunk, then why did they have a camera? Why did they record the whole thing? If they were drunk and recorded it, [by mistake] they would have regreted it, yet they kept sending the video to others?!MaNiElla said:
Last time i checked people dont rape one another when they're drunk.
this has nothing to do with them being drunk, its them being stupid.
Rape shouldn't be expected under any circumstances! I agree with your first sentence, but the alcohol is irrelevant. These guys forced themselves onto a vulnerable girl and raped her; within this situation there's no excuse for their actions, and I hope the justice system has them imprisoned for no less then 10 years.MaNiElla said:
MaNiElla
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2007
- Messages
- 1,853
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- N/A
what i meant was, this --> you have like 7 sick druken dudes, and one completly drunken girl, it was obviuos that the guys would attack her becuase she's drunk and weak, and they're like a group of 7 guys. Its not like the girl invited them to rape her, they were the idiots that took advantage of her in that state.
As for the camera, i know that its bad for them to use it. BUT, If they didnt take the video, the girl would have no clue on what happend to her, because she didnt know that she got raped only after she saw the video. When the guys dumped her infront of her house, she told her mum that she doesnt remember the previous nights events. So, the guys would now get punished for their crime, and its all thanks to the camera. Eventhough it is a shame that this video was spread around in this way...
As for the camera, i know that its bad for them to use it. BUT, If they didnt take the video, the girl would have no clue on what happend to her, because she didnt know that she got raped only after she saw the video. When the guys dumped her infront of her house, she told her mum that she doesnt remember the previous nights events. So, the guys would now get punished for their crime, and its all thanks to the camera. Eventhough it is a shame that this video was spread around in this way...
- Status