MedVision ad

Best exercises to lose weight (2 Viewers)

hYperTrOphY

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2004
Messages
762
Location
Mount Druitt
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
P_Dilemma said:
There are two aims with this "low weight, high rep" style:

1/ Weight loss. Low weights and high reps allows for breathing (cardio), whereas high weights and low reps put emphasis on power. Try lifting a 500k barbell next time; your first instinct isn't to breathe deep.
lol! If breathing makes you lose weight no living person would be overweight!! Even low weights / high reps is anaerobic, not aerobic, so I disagree.
Moreover, while I have not lifted a 500kg barbell, I do lift as heavy as I can, and still breathe. In fact, breathing is essential even more so when lifting super-heavy weight in my opinion.

2/ Balance. I know people who lose weight, only to be left with flabby, fat-less skin. Low weights and high reps will help with toning the muscles.
But 'toning' is about reducing fat, so wouldn't point 2 be the same as point 1?

Doesn't lots of reps at low weight encourage long, lean muscles, whereas low reps at high weight increase bulk (think bodybuilders)...thats what my brothers told me, anyway.
Nope, it is a general misconception which has been perpetuated to a degree that it is considered factual - but I would disagree.
What do you mean by "lean muscles"? Muscles are lean. It is when you have fat on top of them that your body doesn't look lean and your muscles aren't 'defined'. For example, everyone has abs. Doing sit-ups and other abdominal training will not 'give you abs', it will only increase their size and strength. For them to be visible, the fat covering them has to be removed - which is achieved through aerobic means, not anaerobic.

The other word I hate (other than toning) is 'bulk' - what do you mean by this? Muscles increase in size due to resistance training, but their (or your) leanness is not determined by the way in which you lift. Leanness, toning, bulk etc are words which describe overall body composition - muscle to fat. The muscle elements is [primarily] determined by resistance training and protein intake and the fat element determined and affected by cardio training and diet.
 

P_Dilemma

Extraordinary Entertainer
Joined
Oct 18, 2004
Messages
752
Location
The Void
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
hYperTrOphY said:
lol! If breathing makes you lose weight no living person would be overweight!! Even low weights / high reps is anaerobic, not aerobic, so I disagree.
Moreover, while I have not lifted a 500kg barbell, I do lift as heavy as I can, and still breathe. In fact, breathing is essential even more so when lifting super-heavy weight in my opinion.
Ok, i see i wasn't specific enough...

When lifting heavy weights, sure you can breathe. I've seen some huge guys lifting almost all of the gym equipment, going "ARGH! huff, huff, huff... ARGH! puff, puff, puff... ARGH!". But in heavy lifting, breathing isn't the main focus; power is. Breathing here acts more like a cooling system than for weight loss.

The kind of breathing i'm referring to in the low weights, high reps, is breathing for getting more oxygen circulating throughout the whole body. Fat needs oxygen in order to be converted to energy.

hYperTrOphY said:
But 'toning' is about reducing fat, so wouldn't point 2 be the same as point 1?
Ok, wording problem. I think muscle "definition" was what i was after...

hYperTrOphY said:
Nope, it is a general misconception which has been perpetuated to a degree that it is considered factual - but I would disagree.
What do you mean by "lean muscles"? Muscles are lean. It is when you have fat on top of them that your body doesn't look lean and your muscles aren't 'defined'. For example, everyone has abs. Doing sit-ups and other abdominal training will not 'give you abs', it will only increase their size and strength. For them to be visible, the fat covering them has to be removed - which is achieved through aerobic means, not anaerobic.

The other word I hate (other than toning) is 'bulk' - what do you mean by this? Muscles increase in size due to resistance training, but their (or your) leanness is not determined by the way in which you lift. Leanness, toning, bulk etc are words which describe overall body composition - muscle to fat. The muscle elements is [primarily] determined by resistance training and protein intake and the fat element determined and affected by cardio training and diet.
oh, ur so pedantic, ya dun hafta take that guy so literally...

loquasagacious said:
I believe the idea behind low weights high reps is to make it almost cardio as opposed to weight lifting.

As far as your second point though Dilemma you're way wide of the mark. Muscles do not 'tone up'. When you tone up (or cut - to use a term from bodybuilding) you are simply loosing fat (and often some muscle as well). You're muscles do not change however when you strip the fat off they are more prominent eg more toned.

Jumping back abit - 'bruce lee style running' is High intesity Interval Training (HIT), this is a training technique of turning an aerobic exercise (eg running, swimming, cycling) into an anabolic one. The principle is basic once you have warmed up you go all out for a minute and then you slow off for at least two minutes and then go all out again. Repeat this cycle for as long as you are able. It is great for building endurance and lightning speed. It is the recommended training for all fighters (be they boxers, or martial arts miscellaneous) for these reasons.
Again, forgive me for my bad choice of words... gonna have to work on that.

Didn't know the proper name was "HIT". Thanks for that.

-P_D
 

fernando

Poo
Joined
Jul 21, 2004
Messages
839
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
DANCING! free style dancing, crazy dancing, anything-that-involvements-movement dancing! works all part of the body!!
 

hYperTrOphY

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2004
Messages
762
Location
Mount Druitt
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Ok, i see i wasn't specific enough...

When lifting heavy weights, sure you can breathe. I've seen some huge guys lifting almost all of the gym equipment, going "ARGH! huff, huff, huff... ARGH! puff, puff, puff... ARGH!". But in heavy lifting, breathing isn't the main focus; power is. Breathing here acts more like a cooling system than for weight loss.

The kind of breathing i'm referring to in the low weights, high reps, is breathing for getting more oxygen circulating throughout the whole body. Fat needs oxygen in order to be converted to energy.
I still don't quite understand... Oxygen's availability is dependent on the duration of exercise - not the way in which you breathe.
There could be an argument that because more reps would increase duration, there would be an increased chance of oxygen presence. Whilst I do not have the time to research this possibility, I would suggest it is rather irrelevent anyway. If one wants to lose weight, they should be doing what is optimal for fat loss, which is cardio. Doing weight training for the benefits of weight loss, while impractical and unsupported (in this thread), would be far from optimal. By doing so, reps would have to increase to an amount that would negate the chance for muscular hypertrophy and/or strength - which is the purpose of resistance training. Also note, that even if resistance training could be aerobic, fat loss would not be burned from the area(s) in which youwere training. This is referred to as spot reduction and is a myth.

oh, ur so pedantic, ya dun hafta take that guy so literally...
I perceived what she said as literal. She was informed of something from her brother, and I believe what she described is exactly what most people accept as fact.
 

P_Dilemma

Extraordinary Entertainer
Joined
Oct 18, 2004
Messages
752
Location
The Void
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
hYperTrOphY said:
I still don't quite understand... Oxygen's availability is dependent on the duration of exercise - not the way in which you breathe.
There could be an argument that because more reps would increase duration, there would be an increased chance of oxygen presence. Whilst I do not have the time to research this possibility, I would suggest it is rather irrelevent anyway. If one wants to lose weight, they should be doing what is optimal for fat loss, which is cardio.
Well, with more reps, the duration would be longer than low reps/ more weights.

Deep breathing would provide more oxygen than short, shallow breaths (ARGH! huff, huff, huff... ARGH! puff, puff, puff... ARGH!).

But you're right, cardio would be the primary method for weight loss. low weights, high reps (plus breathing!) would be secondary...

-P_D
 

hipsta_jess

Up the mighty red V
Joined
May 30, 2003
Messages
5,981
Gender
Female
HSC
N/A
hYperTrOphY said:
What do you mean by "lean muscles"?
You know, like the 'long, lean' sexiness that the infomercials on Pilates promises

The other word I hate (other than toning) is 'bulk' - what do you mean by this?
Big, chunky muscles like body builders or even some footballers.
 

loquasagacious

NCAP Mooderator
Joined
Aug 3, 2004
Messages
3,636
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2004
Well im guessing but in that context I would suppose that lean muscles refer to a toned physique. eg only muscles as opposed to muscles+fat.

As an academic point I have heard the term lean muscle used not to describe all muscle mass as hypertrophy suggested but rather to describe the 'actual' muscle mass. In that for bodybuilders (especially those on creatine) their muscle fibres are swelled by water mass giving them that pumped up look. So visible muscle mass equals lean muscle+water/etc.

Moving on to the bulk issue the problem with this term is it is simply a size descriptor. Bulk as a term can be used to describe total size of a person be they fat or built. My personal take on it is that muscle bulk describes total size and tone describes their definition in terms of a %bodyfat.
 

hYperTrOphY

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2004
Messages
762
Location
Mount Druitt
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
hipsta_jess said:
You know, like the 'long, lean' sexiness that the infomercials on Pilates promises


Big, chunky muscles like body builders or even some footballers.
lol, you just defined it by using the same description/word. There is little difference between the muscles (other than the development of predominantly fast-twicth or slow-twitch mucle fibres) of people who look, as you describe it, long and lean, and those who you describe as bulky.
The main difference between the people in those pilate infomercials and bodybuilders is the size of their muscles, not their leanness or length.
In fact, bodybuilder are actually leaner in terms of their bodyfat percentage.

For example: Ronnie Coleman (bodybuilder) is leaner than most, although you would probably describe his as bulky/chunky.

EDIT: Another interesting fact for you to think about is that he doesn't train with low reps.

 

gordo

Resident Jew
Joined
Feb 5, 2004
Messages
2,352
Location
bondi, sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
jog, sprint, push ups, sprint, jog, situps, jog, sprint, squats, sprint, jog repeat...
 

Qlimax

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2006
Messages
38
Gender
Male
HSC
2003
Go to a weekly rave event like sublime or plastic (www.echild.info to get some information about when the events are on)
take 1 pill
dump them in halves and dance all fkn night
 

MzbLaZeIT

im am teh seks.
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
623
Location
<- back that way
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
Qlimax said:
Go to a weekly rave event like sublime or plastic (www.echild.info to get some information about when the events are on)
take 1 pill
dump them in halves and dance all fkn night
lmaoooooo so many of my fat friends who used to go raving, are unbelievable skinny now! lol

smoking weeed nearly everyday helps weight loss also.
lol
 

Always

Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2005
Messages
632
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
^^^ I agree. When I used to go to raves I'd lose up to 3 kgs each time. Most of my friends were able to lose 5 kgs.

Raves are not glamorous but they're sort've fun in a crazy way and best of all, they're great for losing weight quickly. ;)
 

Qlimax

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2006
Messages
38
Gender
Male
HSC
2003
Exactly, the best way to lose weight, although it still is very unusual to see that there are so many fat ravers out there that rave occasionally
 

Bourkey

New Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Messages
11
Location
Dubbo
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
I ride my horse three times a wk for an hour or two, depending on how much energy i have. then have to walk him back to his paddock which is a km away frm my house. So its a 2km round walk to get him then take him back as well as the work out during the ride as well. This i think is the best workout as horse riding uses like all the muscles in teh body. Especially a trot for a km then a long canter, then you go for a gallop. This is not only exercising, it also SO much fun to do. The days that i dont ride, i still have to go chek him as well. SO its a 2km walk a day, 7 days a wk. So yeah its the money that i had to spend on gettinh him then keeping him fed and looked after proberly, was a good investment 4 me on a fitness level.....!!
 

wanton-wonton

Active Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2004
Messages
1,415
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Bourkey said:
I ride my horse three times a wk for an hour or two, depending on how much energy i have. then have to walk him back to his paddock which is a km away frm my house. So its a 2km round walk to get him then take him back as well as the work out during the ride as well. This i think is the best workout as horse riding uses like all the muscles in teh body. Especially a trot for a km then a long canter, then you go for a gallop. This is not only exercising, it also SO much fun to do. The days that i dont ride, i still have to go chek him as well. SO its a 2km walk a day, 7 days a wk. So yeah its the money that i had to spend on gettinh him then keeping him fed and looked after proberly, was a good investment 4 me on a fitness level.....!!
Location: Whoop Whoop
 

loquasagacious

NCAP Mooderator
Joined
Aug 3, 2004
Messages
3,636
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2004
Comparitively riding a horse and walking a km is a very shit exercise.

If you want to loose weight then exercises you should do are:

Running,
Cycling,
Swimming,
Rowing.

If you want to loose weight and gain strength then you should also do compound movement exercises eg:

Pushup
Sit up
Squat
Lunge
Chin-up/pull-up
Tricep dip
 

Bourkey

New Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Messages
11
Location
Dubbo
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
Ok yes it may seem that way, but have u eva riden a horse???????
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)

Top