Search results

Comrade, he killed the whole bolshevik party and eliminated trotsky from history.. before putting an ice pick in the back of his head, you are really insane in calling stalin socialist, you give the movement a bad name...

that wasnt a shot at you danie that was a shot at "not-That-Bright" and "Comrade Nathan" . I actually regard you as a cool one in this thread!!

Are you a member, thats what i understood from previous posts, because if you are a member you definitely are...?

As i said before my awesome reply got lost twice by IE, i have just thought of an analogy to your theory that may bring some light on it. If someone sufferes a bad leg wound and has it amputated, its not a precondition for their death but beheading is, even though this is quite grousome, no...

Hey Danie By the tone of your argument, that i didnt get to before my first post, yuo seem like a descent person to chat to in that you, unlike the other people here seem open to ideas. Marxist economic theory doesnt advocate equall pay but rather a closer differential from highest paid to...

Comrade Nathan It is at this point in my argument that I come out gunes plazing against your Stalinist politics and that of the CP. In my rebuttal the other night i wrote it twice had it crash twice and gave up but I can intergrate the response into this one. deusexmachina are you in the...

Ive seen motorcycle diaries and the only glorification of Che is the fact that he vists medical centres and gives a damn about universal health and education. I'm not sure what that columnist was agitated about because the film never got into "revolutionary tacticts or methods" but just showed...

Not that im particularly partial on the issue, but that argument stems from the argument of the 70's where the conclusions of the May June France uprising where the masses of students radicalised by the vietnam confict took over factories and brought de gaull to his knees and at this time the...

Working Class revolution When you say we believe the aus working class has rev potential do you mean that your view differs only on the aus situation or you believe first world working classes are incapable because their is plenty of evidence to contradict that. In saying that do you not...

I didnt mean to offend any vietnamese if i did, the post above was about communist theory and said nothing about the problems of vietnamese socialism and that was intentional... im not debating something i havent seen and know little about

I think what we have is a school text book definition, by Marx, the reliable one, since he made the theory comrae nathan is correct. Maybe some teacher told you that that was what communism is but in fact that was probably just what stalinist or pol pot communism was, which is obviously a total...

Socialist Alliance Yeh, Im in the Socialist Alliance and Resistance, socialist alliance is pretty exciting coz its growing so quick since 1999 when it was formed from 9 different parties mainly the DSP - Democratic Socialist Perspective and the ISO - International Socialist Organisation...

Mass Action Hi In regards to the NRMA, there are actually some really cool people working on our side saying how stupid the stuff is... They organized a forum in wollonging atracted media and got our oppinions heard... the real problem for us is getting those views out there... we need a...

Ive found the Bolsheviks I really dilike not living in sydney there is a distinct lack of leftists and their ideologies... Its excellent that you guys can have a proper discussion that analyses the issues wholeheartedly, the intelectuallity and intelligence of the Labor left postings is a...