MedVision ad

Creative Piece Review (1 Viewer)

Righty-0

New Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2003
Messages
12
Hey

I was wondering if i could get some feedback on this creative writing piece my friend wrote
the aim was to write to a similar style to 'Sky High' in the stimulus booklet.. u noe.... descriptive and stuff.. not plot driven..
so yeah
wat can be improved? wat are some good points?

In an instant, the deep dark and dry creak bed became embedded with the cool crystal clear water, like a tidal wave hitting a Mediterranean city as the hot and humid air hits the cool chill of winter from the South American Alps.

The sudden gleam of joy hitting my face as if there were strings, intricately attached to my facial muscles being pulled by a skilful puppeteer.

The sweltering warmth of the sparkling lemon-orange sun hit the racy river as the water formed a mixture with the bare brown earth.

I remember that the river ran between the town centre, trickling playfully past the worn down buildings and circling half of it like an eagle circling its prey. The town was filled with silence.

Almost immediately, the town was filled with little inhabitants, bustling through. As I picture it, they were much like micro ants, little black men bobbing boastfully to and fro. A wonky, weary and worn out leaf carried them from one end of the seemingly slow and smooth river.

Not far from there, I sat, overwhelmed with the wondrous, yet enchanting city, which I have been able to magnificently craft.

The sweltering sunlight stopped as the sudden movements of the dark and deceitful clouds quickly settled in. The once magnificent city was now dark and dangerous. All the townsfolk had already retreated resentfully into their homes, burrowing deep below the eccentric earth to shield itself from this destructive monster. The sound of the rain, pitter and pattering down hard on the soft sandy dirt rumbled the city like mega boom boxes playing music full notch in a Toyota Echo. As one drop after another came pounding down, the buildings began to crumble under the immense pressure of the buckets of water pouring down. The river began to over flood into the once magnificent and magical city, destroying all the hard artisanship that went into it.

I sat there in awe, furiously frustrated. As my grandma hurriedly hustled me back in the house, I took one last look at the damage to the city and reluctantly made my way back into our white, worn down weatherboard house.

As soon as the rain stopped, I ran outside to face to ruins of the ravaged wreck of the city. It had been reduced into a pile of mud. Much like the mud that I had begun with. The magnificent and magical city was made into a muddy mess.

As time passes, this muddy mess has become infested with weeds and worms. I wince at the thought of touching it. I shiver at the sheer sight. I cringe at the smell of it. Though I wonder... I wonder about the joy it had brought to me. The childhood penchant remains somewhere possibly the size of a pin inside a haystack, but it will never be found. The decade of morals, education, pressure, and movies has reduced the playful childs perspective and endorsed right from wrong. It has defined black from white, denoting greys and shades between and subconsciously inscribed propaganda, law regulations mixed in with a hint of humour for flavour and spice.
 

Azn fairies

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Messages
273
Location
Sydney
this story is a bit to clinched! ...like a lot of people would use it and think of it...need to be creative!.

aslo the word choice can tell any reader that he.she is trying to hard!!, not impressive. well that's my opion.
 

SmokedSalmon

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2003
Messages
900
Location
for me to know and for you to find out
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
*clap clap*

Originally posted by Azn fairies
this story is a bit to clinched! ...like a lot of people would use it and think of it...need to be creative!.
Are you crazy? How is that cliched? I'm sorry I didn't find it cliched at all :) Good job Righty-O. Better then what I can pull out of my a$$. However just have to remark about the grammer i.e. the boom boxes... that anology (sp?) doesn't suit the story too well. Overall a good piece. But hey i could be a leniant marker.

now can someone tell me a story that is not freaking CLICHED??? I loathe that word with a passion.
 

rukawasan

Top Stuff
Joined
Jun 2, 2003
Messages
610
Gender
Male
HSC
2003
did the person who wrote this write under exam conditions?
 

Azn fairies

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Messages
273
Location
Sydney
err.. this story was bascailyl a copy of a band 6 repsonds from 2001 HSC ..but changed it a bit.. also i seen these kind of repsonse a lot. SO IT"S CLICHED!!!
look at band 4-6 reponse from past HSC
 

SmokedSalmon

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2003
Messages
900
Location
for me to know and for you to find out
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
My apologies

I didn't realise it was a copy of a response from 2001 :p Didn't mean to bite down ur throat Azn Fairies just getting infuriated by the concept of change. My last two stories under exam conditions were deemed cliched and I still don't understand why. I believe its because of my lack of imagination... bah humbug . :mad1:
 

picaresque

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2003
Messages
155
Location
'the russian winters are endless...'
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
Not bad. Too much superfluous description, rhythmically it's a bit off and the subject matter could be more original. It seems...a little bit childish in places eg. 'the sparkling lemon-orange sun' and 'the dark and deceitful clouds'. The choice of vocab wasn't always integrated smoothly into the piece either, eg. 'hard artisanship' just doesn't read right.

But these are all fairly minor stylistic nit-picks. Over all, if this was written under exam conditions, it's not a bad piece.
 

numg

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2003
Messages
59
Location
Randwick
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
Its seems like a very good response displaying a lot of techniques. Is it just me though or does it seem overdone? and does it matter if it is? the whole imagery and all just don't work well as a whole and quickly reading that response, it didn't really make much coherent sense.
 

picaresque

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2003
Messages
155
Location
'the russian winters are endless...'
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
Originally posted by numg
quickly reading that response, it didn't really make much coherent sense.
I can't be bothered to check again, but are the tenses consistent? Because you're right - something about it doesn't gel, like the writer just lumped descriptive clauses together and then placed strategic punctuation in.
 

Newbie

is a roflcopter
Joined
May 17, 2003
Messages
3,670
Gender
Male
HSC
2003
i think its pretty good.........

*adds to collection of stolen essays*
 

dirty dave

Banned
Joined
Aug 30, 2003
Messages
244
Location
macca town
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
it's pretty good, but again, there is something that doesn't seem right. still bettr than anything i can do. howmuch do you ppl think its gonna get if its done under exam conditions ?
 

numg

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2003
Messages
59
Location
Randwick
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
depends on how it'll answer the text type and stuff, but i'd hazard a 13/14 outta 15.

If anyone thinks its bad maybe they could put up a better one?? :D
 

numg

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2003
Messages
59
Location
Randwick
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
*Scales target marks down a lot* :p

Yea, i agree with what you said on this piece. Won't be perfect but like a band 6, or maybe high band 5 in worst case scenario.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top