My friend was talking about this the other day but how is it fair that math ext 1 kids compete with us kids who just does adv. Cause they know like better graphing techniques and other problem solving problems that they learnt in ext which they can use in adv. Like they already automatically take the first 10 ranks. And then English ext kids are just too good so can they just not compete with us adv kids for ranks. Like it's fine for them to take the course but they shouldn't be ranked against us
And also it doesn't make sense how in mx2, adv doesn't count but in ee2 it does
I can explain the math ext 2 vs eng ext 2 thing, basically the skills in math stack so technically in mxx they test you on stuff from advanced anyways
Eng ext 2 not only doesn't have an exam but also it technically doesn't test the skills taught in adv (e.g. if I do a critical essay I go through year 12 without needing to learn how to write a discursive)
Think about it this way - not everyone can do math ext 2, but technically anyone could do eng ext 2 at a somewhat markable standard even they cobbled together some random ChatGPT garbage into a creative
Obvi they're not gonna do well if they did that but if they could just skip eng adv, get the better scaling and put less effort then everybody is gonna be doing 4U eng
The metaphor I've heard is math ext 2 is like adding another floor on top of your house - it relies on a strong foundation - whereas eng ext 2 is like a grannyflat that's still on the same plot of land but could still stand even without the house
As for the ranking thing in my school at least the adv kids still put up a good fight for the top ranks, and wdym it's not fair? If they get the same rank in the HSC it's literally no different, like if somebody gets 1st internal and 1st external its basically the same as if they get 10th internal and 10th external with the exact same mark, heck the person who got 10th might even do better bc their internal gets moderated up more (I take ur point about ext math knowing more techniques though, that's fair)
I might be biased as an ext kid tho