Israel and Palestine (3 Viewers)

[Not-That-Bright]

Re: The History of Israel, Zionism and U.S support by Prof. Schleifer

This did not require a new thread.

Merged.

 

[Nebuchanezzar]

Re: The History of Israel, Zionism and U.S support by Prof. Schleifer

Aw, now it looks like everyone was referring to my post.

 

[S1M0]

My proposal:

Spoiler

End this thread. End all threads that include Palestine vs Israel in any shape or form.

 

[HotShot]

My proposal:

Spoiler

End this thread. End all threads that include Palestine vs Israel in any shape or form.

NEIN otherwise there isnt fun to talk about!!!!

And - Somehow other threads - will get back ontp ISrael vs PAlestine. Somehow..

 

[JaredR]

I am all for healthy debate and I particularly have an interest in the State of Israel which I will pursue and defend by all measures. I agree though, this debate is worn and there's nothing new being discussed - just the same repetitive nonsense. I've lost interest.

I say close the thread, and if somene wants to open a new one in the future - I hope it has a fresh approach.

 

[extraordinary07]

I am all for healthy debate and I particularly have an interest in the State of Israel which I will pursue and defend by all measures. I agree though, this debate is worn and there's nothing new being discussed - just the same repetitive nonsense. I've lost interest.

I say close the thread, and if somene wants to open a new one in the future - I hope it has a fresh approach.

well put good sir! your deeds will be noted by all members. i bestow upon you the upmost applause.

hossana in the highset!

 

[JaredR]

Smart ass. lol.

 

[extraordinary07]

Smart ass. lol.

just a joke. you can never really tell can you?

 

[ur_inner_child]

I'm pretty sure many agree that this thread has well and truly ended.

Honestly I am quite sick of NCAP being flooded with such similar topics.
It deters many members.

For the second time, stop. Those who either start these threads, or hijack perfectly well constructed threads on Israel or on Muslims, please stop.

 

[Not-That-Bright]

Israel & Palestine

This is the thread for all discussions relevant to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict other than those which are of such public prominence in the news that they reasonably warrant a new thread.

I know this is a heated topic for many on this forum, but please try to keep discussions sensible and maintain some sort of respect towards each other - I will be watching this thread closely.

Your loving Moderator,

Chadd.

 

[jenzipoo]

Re: Israel & Palestine

seeing as everyone is twidling their thumbs and waiting for something to happen ill start with a question.

do you think the palestinian people have a right of return to israeli land?

 

[simplistic]

Re: Israel & Palestine

well y are u callin it israeli land? last time i cheaked it was called Jerusalem ?

 

[jenzipoo]

Re: Israel & Palestine

well y are u callin it israeli land? last time i cheaked it was called Jerusalem ?

huh??

palestinians' plea for a right of return is return to the land that is israel..not just the city/area of jerusalem

 

[HotShot]

Re: Israel & Palestine

huh??

palestinians' plea for a right of return is return to the land that is israel..not just the city/area of jerusalem

No..

That land doesnt belong to Israel anyway. Israel doesnt exist - it is not recognised by the Palestinians.

 

[nathan71088]

Re: Israel & Palestine

No..

That land doesnt belong to Israel anyway. Israel doesnt exist - it is not recognised by the Palestinians.

Enough of this conceptual rubbish. Do not come in here and debate Israel's existence. Do not tell me it does not exist. There is a plot of land that lies between Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Palestine etc. It is under Israeli rule. Israel owns that land. Do not say anything about stealing or annexing or any other emotionally fuelled cry baby whingy nonsense. Ownership...sure argue all you want. Who has the right to it, who deserves it...even better, clearly this is controversial. But existence...And do not tell me that I am misinterpreting this or taking it too literal. Existence is a well defined term, you have used it with it's full intent. Israel exists...period

 

[onebytwo]

Re: Israel & Palestine

Enough of this conceptual rubbish. Do not come in here and debate Israel's existence. Do not tell me it does not exist. There is a plot of land that lies between Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Palestine etc. It is under Israeli rule. Israel owns that land. Do not say anything about stealing or annexing or any other emotionally fuelled cry baby whingy nonsense. Ownership...sure argue all you want. Who has the right to it, who deserves it...even better, clearly this is controversial. But existence...And do not tell me that I am misinterpreting this or taking it too literal. Existence is a well defined term, you have used it with it's full intent. Israel exists...period

so why are israelis and the west so obsessed with the palestinians seeing israels right to exist if, as you say, it already physically exists?

 

[S1M0]

Re: Israel & Palestine

Enough of this conceptual rubbish. Do not come in here and debate Israel's existence. Do not tell me it does not exist. There is a plot of land that lies between Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Palestine etc. It is under Israeli rule. Israel owns that land. Do not say anything about stealing or annexing or any other emotionally fuelled cry baby whingy nonsense. Ownership...sure argue all you want. Who has the right to it, who deserves it...even better, clearly this is controversial. But existence...And do not tell me that I am misinterpreting this or taking it too literal. Existence is a well defined term, you have used it with it's full intent. Israel exists...period

Your knowledge and conception of the middle eat conflict is limited to a severe fault. In other words, shut up.

 

[bored6]

Re: Israel & Palestine

Enough of this conceptual rubbish. Do not come in here and debate Israel's existence. Do not tell me it does not exist. There is a plot of land that lies between Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Palestine etc. It is under Israeli rule. Israel owns that land. Do not say anything about stealing or annexing or any other emotionally fuelled cry baby whingy nonsense. Ownership...sure argue all you want. Who has the right to it, who deserves it...even better, clearly this is controversial. But existence...And do not tell me that I am misinterpreting this or taking it too literal. Existence is a well defined term, you have used it with it's full intent. Israel exists...period

Israel doesn't exist.















































lol @ you, silly zionist.

 

[jb_nc]

Re: Israel & Palestine

No..

That land doesnt belong to Israel anyway. Israel doesnt exist - it is not recognised by the Palestinians.

You're wrong. Israel exists, recognised by the UN and Western Nations. Palestine doesn't exist.

lol @ you, silly zionist.

Great posting there man. Everyone who defends Israel is a 'Zionist' much like everyone who defends Palestine is an 'Islamic extremist'.

 

[onebytwo]

Re: Israel & Palestine

Great posting there man. Everyone who defends Israel is a 'Zionist' much like everyone who defends Palestine is an 'Islamic extremist'.

being a zionist doesnt, or shouldnt, carry such a negative connotation as you make it to have. its as though any israeli supporters feel offended or insulted by being refered to as zionist.